Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 300.8 Guidance

User: hutch75, Location: Detroit, MI

Asked on: Friday, February 18, 2011 at 2:26 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:47 am EDT

Question: In review of a machine design an OEM proposed running mechanical systems(weld water) and electrical systems(480v) in an upper structure floor. Both the electrical and mechanical were to be run in a common channel(24" widex12" high) with removeable floor covers. I rejected the installation due to 300.8 requiring those systems to not be run in the same tray. My thought process was that this entire 24" trough was the raceway and this installation was prohibited. Mechanical to be run in hoses, and the electrical in TC-ER cables.They redesigned the machine and installed two separate trays below the machine balcony to carry these systems. Since this is a standard design built for world wide customers, I am now getting challenged to allow this installation.I have reviewed NFPA 79 and understand it allows using structures for raceways as long as we stay away from hydraulic fluids..Any advice.

NFPA 79 Considerations

NFPA 79, Section 5.1.7, allows the use of structures as raceways for electrical systems, provided that the following conditions are met: The structure is noncombustible or protected with an approved fire-resistant coating. The structure is not subject to damage from exposure to the electrical system or its contents. The structure is not used as a raceway for hydraulic fluids.

Specific Installation in Question

In the case presented, the installation involves both electrical and mechanical systems (weld water) in a common channel. While the structure (floor covers) is noncombustible, it is unclear whether it is protected with an approved fire-resistant coating. Additionally, the presence of weld water, which is a hydraulic fluid, may violate the requirement not to use structures for raceways of hydraulic fluids.

Interpretation and Recommendations

Based on the information provided, it is not clear if the proposed installation meets the requirements of NFPA 79, Section 5.1.
7. The following recommendations are suggested:
Verify Fire-Resistance Rating

Determine if the floor covers are protected with an approved fire-resistant coating.

Consider Separate Trays

Explore the option of using separate trays for the electrical and mechanical systems, even if they are located below the machine balcony. This would ensure compliance with NFPA 79 and 300.8.


Consult with Electrical Engineer

Seek advice from a qualified electrical engineer who can provide guidance on the specific requirements of the installation and the applicable codes.

Document Compliance

Clearly document the reasoning behind the decision and provide evidence of compliance with relevant codes and standards.

Additional Considerations
Maintenance and Accessibility

Ensure that the location of the electrical and mechanical systems in the floor trough allows for proper maintenance and access to the equipment.*

Safety:
Consider potential hazards such as electrical shock or fluid leaks and assess the adequacy of safety measures in the installation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question