User: esox39, Location: Chicago, IL
Asked on: Sunday, February 20, 2011 at 10:33 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:49 am EDT
Question: I have a situation. I have 2 non reversing industrial ceiling fans. 1 speed controller operates both. 120V .70 amps. Fan A is 40 feet from the speed controller. Fan B is 55 feet from the controller. Both are mounted on 10' ceiling. When we turn on the fans, Fan A spins dramatically faster than Fan B. The manufacturer sends a new fan. We replace Fan A with the new one. Same results. We replace Fan B with the one we took down and again, same results. Wiring is in conduit, with switch leg conductors for general lighting. We re pulled conductors to be sure of proper wiring and no crossed neutrals. Same results. Does anyone have any insight as to why 2 fans 15 feet from each other run at 2 different speeds? Thanks for all the help.Ron
Possible Reasons for Disparity in Fan Speeds
Resistance in Wiring
The longer wire run to Fan B (55 feet) introduces higher resistance, which can reduce current flow and slow down the fan.
Voltage Drop
As current travels through the wire, it experiences a voltage drop. The longer the wire, the greater the voltage drop, resulting in lower voltage at Fan B, which can slow it down.
Electrical Interference
Other electrical devices or wiring in the vicinity of the fans may create electrical interference that affects the speed of Fan B.
Fan Motor Differences
Although both fans are the same model, there may be slight variations in their motor windings or other components that could lead to differences in speed.
Air Flow Obstructions
Obstructions in the air flow path of Fan B, such as nearby walls, furniture, or other fans, can impede its rotation and slow it down.
Troubleshooting Steps
Measure Voltage at Each Fan
Use a voltmeter to check the voltage at both fans. If the voltage is significantly lower at Fan B, it could confirm the resistance or voltage drop issue.
Inspect Wiring Connections
Ensure all wire connections are tight and secure. Loose connections can create additional resistance and affect fan speed.
Reverse Fan Connections
Temporarily switch the wiring connections between the fans to see if the speed disparity reverses. This will help determine if it's a wiring or fan motor issue.
Test Fans with Separate Speed Controllers
If possible, connect each fan to a separate speed controller and observe their speeds. This will eliminate the possibility of the speed controller influencing the disparity.
Consult with an Electrician: If you are unable to resolve the issue yourself, it's recommended to consult with a qualified electrician who can perform more advanced troubleshooting and determine the exact cause of the speed difference. Flag for review