User: mikeybmdb32, Location: Tennessee NEC:2017
Asked on: Tuesday, February 22, 2011 at 9:36 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:55 am EDT
Question: I have a situation where an old switchgear, which used to be the main service for the building, is now downstream from a new switchgear which now serves as the service entry. The new switchgear neutral and ground are bonded as required by NEC. However, the old switchgear still has a bonding jumper which bonds neutral to ground. I have asked the contractor to remove the bonding jumper in the old, downstream switchgear, but he is reluctant as he says the code does not require it.I've heard that having two bonds can cause ground loops, but is it also a safety issue? Is there anything in the code that forbids having bonds in two different locations?
Code Requirements
NEC 250.32 requires bonding of the neutral and grounding electrode system at the service entrance. In this case, the new switchgear is the service entrance and has a bonded neutral. Therefore, no additional bonding is required downstream at the old switchgear.
Safety Concerns
Ground loops
Multiple bonding points can create ground loops, which can lead to nuisance tripping of ground fault protection devices (GFCIs) and cause other electrical malfunctions.
Neutral-to-ground potential difference
With two bonding points, there can be a potential difference between the neutral and ground at the downstream switchgear, which can result in electrical shocks or damage to equipment.
NEC Implications
NEC 250.32(A)(4) states: "The grounded conductor shall not be connected to the equipment grounding conductor on the load side of any service disconnecting means or overcurrent device except as in 250.26(E) [for separately derived systems]." NEC 250.26(E) permits separate bonding of a separately derived system, but this does not apply to downstream equipment connected to a grounded service entrance.
Recommendation:
The bonding jumper in the old, downstream switchgear should be removed to avoid potential code violations, safety hazards, and electrical malfunctions. The new switchgear serves as the primary bonding point for the entire system, and additional bonding downstream is unnecessary and potentially detrimental. Flag for review