User: james_mcquade, Location: Illinois
Asked on: Wednesday, February 23, 2011 at 6:15 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:58 am EDT
Question: Hi everyone,Please clear up something for me.We are ordering a mcc with 20 buckets for a new addition to the plant.We have always placed a disconnect at the motor, but for this install, we will not be using the disconnects at the motors. The engineer says that the electric code allows us to lock out the mcc bucket.the mcc is in one room and the motors are up to several hunderd feet away.I understand the lock out tag out, but what about the within sight rule.as always, thanks in advance.james.
Electrical Code and Lockout/Tagout
The National Electrical Code (NEC) allows for lockout tagout (LOTO) to be utilized for disconnecting equipment, including motor control centers (MCCs). However, LOTO is not a substitute for a disconnect at the motor, which is still required by the NEC.
Within Sight Rule
The within sight rule requires that disconnecting means be located within sight of the equipment being disconnected. This rule applies to both switches and circuit breakers. The exception to the within sight rule is if the disconnecting means is lockable and tagged.
MCC Disconnects and Lockout/Tagout
In your case, the engineer is correct that the NEC allows you to lock out the MCC bucket instead of installing disconnects at the motors. However, this is only permissible if the following conditions are met: The MCC is located in a designated electrical room with limited access. The MCC buckets are clearly labeled to indicate the motors they supply. The MCC and motor terminals are equipped with lockable lockout devices. The lockout devices are used in conjunction with a clear LOTO procedure.
Best Practice
While the NEC allows for LOTO in place of motor disconnects, it is generally considered best practice to install disconnects at the motors. This provides additional safety and convenience, as it allows for local isolation of the motors without having to access the MCC.
Conclusion
You may use LOTO to disconnect the motors from the MCC, provided that you meet the requirements outlined above. However, it is recommended to install disconnects at the motors for increased safety and convenience. Flag for review