User: Rick Christopherson, Location: Wisconsin
Asked on: Thursday, February 24, 2011 at 10:20 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:59 am EDT
Question: I was reading another discussion about high-leg delta systems and the topic turned to breaker ratings on the B-phase (high leg). For a 2-pole breaker utilizing the B-phase, it must be rated 240, not the 120/240 slash-rating. I also confirmed this in the Scheider catalog. But that's not my question.My question is why is this the case? Why should a 2-pole breaker that is intended to see 240 volts between adjacent stabs in the load center need to care about where the grounding point is located? The circuit breaker doesn't know whether its overcurrent trip is due to a short to phase versus a short to ground. It's insulation value still has to be rated for the adjacent buss bar voltage, which is still 240 volts.Does anyone know enough about the internals of the breaker or UL requirements to explain the difference between a 120/240 breaker versus a 240 breaker?
The reason why a 2-pole breaker utilizing the B-phase on a high-leg delta system must be rated 240 and not 120/240 is due to the way the breaker is designed and operates.In a high-leg delta system, the B-phase has a voltage of 240 volts relative to ground, while the A and C phases have a voltage of 120 volts relative to ground. This means that a 2-pole breaker that is connected to the B-phase and an A or C phase will see a voltage of 240 volts between its terminals.If a 120/240 breaker were used in this situation, it would only be rated for a maximum voltage of 120 volts between its terminals. This means that the breaker could potentially trip prematurely if it were subjected to a voltage of 240 volts.In addition, using a 120/240 breaker on a high-leg delta system could create a safety hazard. If a ground fault occurred on the B-phase, the 120/240 breaker would not trip because it would not see a voltage of 120 volts between its terminals. This could result in a dangerous situation where the ground fault is not cleared and could potentially lead to an electrical fire.For these reasons, it is important to use a 240-volt breaker when connecting to the B-phase of a high-leg delta system. This will ensure that the breaker is properly rated for the voltage that it will be subjected to and will provide the necessary protection against overcurrent and ground faults.As for the difference between the internals of a 120/240 breaker and a 240 breaker, the main difference is in the way that the breakers are insulated. A 120/240 breaker is insulated to withstand a maximum voltage of 120 volts between its terminals, while a 240 breaker is insulated to withstand a maximum voltage of 240 volts between its terminals. This difference in insulation is necessary to ensure that the breakers can safely operate at their respective voltage ratings. Flag for review