User: winslowfam, Location: VA
Asked on: Friday, February 25, 2011 at 8:08 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:02 am EDT
Question: We are paying attention to the SCCR (short circuit current rating) of equipment purchased by our clients as we design the power supply to these panels....such as Air Compressors, HVAC equipment, etc. We want to ensure that the panels are rated for the available short circuit curent from the power system where the client wants it installed. When we ask the vendor or OEM for the SCCR of their equipment, we either get a "deer in the headlights" response or they give us a value like 5kA for the rating. This equipment is being fed from 480 volts, so the available short circuit curernt is always greater than 5kA...this forces us to installed current limiting fuses to limit the current these panels will see during a fault. Is this normal for the industry? Are OEM's really unaware of this problem?
Industry Norm
Yes, it is common for vendors and OEMs of equipment to have limited knowledge or provide incorrect information about the SCCR of their products. This is because SCCR is not a commonly specified or tested parameter during equipment design.
Impact on Power System Design
As you have rightly identified, when the SCCR of equipment falls below the available short circuit current, current-limiting fuses or other protective devices must be installed to limit the fault current and protect the equipment. This can increase the cost and complexity of the power supply design.
Reasons for Vendor Unfamiliarity Testing Complexity
SCCR testing requires specialized equipment and procedures, which may not be readily available to all manufacturers.
Lack of Awareness
OEMs may not fully understand the implications of SCCR or its impact on the power system design.
Focus on Other Performance Metrics
OEMs often focus on other performance parameters, such as equipment efficiency or capacity, which may be more critical for their customers.
Addressing the Issue
To address this issue, you can take the following steps: Educate Vendors
Emphasize the importance of SCCR to your clients and explain how it affects the power system design.
Insist on Accurate Information
Request written confirmation from vendors regarding the SCCR rating of their equipment.
Consider Independent Testing
If vendor-provided information is insufficient or unreliable, consider conducting independent SCCR testing to verify the equipment's true rating.*
Design for Worst-Case Scenarios: Assume the available short circuit current is at its maximum when designing the power supply. This will ensure that the system is protected even if vendor-provided SCCR information is inaccurate.By following these steps, you can ensure that the panels you design meet the necessary SCCR requirements and minimize the risk of equipment damage due to short circuits. Flag for review