User: esg970, Location: Illinois
Asked on: Friday, February 25, 2011 at 8:33 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:03 am EDT
Question: I have a spec interpretation question.The specs read:1. Exposed, Not Subject to Physical Damage: EMT.2. Exposed and Subject to Severe Physical Damage: Rigid steel conduit. Includes raceways in the following locations:a. Loading Dockb. Corridors used for traffic of mechanized carts, forklifts, and pallet-handling units.c. Mechanical roomsWe feel that some, but not all conduit in mechanical rooms and corridors should be rigid (If they wanted all conduit in those areas, they should have said ?all? or put it under a different number). We submitted an RFI trying to define ?severe physical damage? in these areas as 6?AFF and below, but the GC said that all conduit in these areas is to be rigid. We disagree and have submitted a change order.Another interesting point is that the controls contractor is allowed to install EMT in these areas.Also, is there a definition of severe physical damage?Any thoughts or input on this would be appreciated.
Interpretation of Specifications
The specifications clearly state that conduit in "exposed and subject to severe physical damage" locations must be rigid steel conduit. The following locations are listed as examples: Loading Dock Corridors for mechanized traffic Mechanical roomsHowever, there is no definition of "severe physical damage" provided in the specifications. This could lead to differing interpretations.
Contractor's Position
The GC's interpretation is that all conduit in mechanical rooms and corridors is subject to severe physical damage and therefore must be rigid.
Subcontractor's Position
The subcontractor argues that not all conduit in these areas is subject to severe physical damage. They contend that conduit installed above 6'AFF is not at risk and can be installed as EMT.
Relevant Code Sections
The National Electrical Code (NEC) does not define the term "severe physical damage." However, it does provide guidance on the use of rigid conduits in certain applications. NEC 352.10(A) requires rigid metal conduit to be used in locations where conduit is "subject to physical damage."* NEC 358.10(B) requires EMT to be installed in locations "not exposed to severe physical damage."Industry Accepted Interpretation
The industry-accepted interpretation of "severe physical damage" is typically based on the potential for impact from equipment or other objects. Conduit installed in areas with heavy traffic or where it is likely to be struck by equipment is considered to be subject to severe physical damage.
Conclusion
Based on the available information, it appears that the GC's interpretation of the specifications is reasonable. However, the subcontractor could potentially make a case that conduit installed above 6'AFF is not subject to severe physical damage and could therefore be installed as EMT.
Recommendation
To resolve this dispute, the parties involved should work together to develop a clear definition of "severe physical damage" as it applies to the specific locations in question. This definition should consider the potential for impact and the likelihood of damage occurring. The parties should also discuss any exceptions that may apply, such as conduit installed above a certain height. Flag for review