User: RobbieR, Location: Atlanta
Asked on: Friday, February 25, 2011 at 8:17 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:05 am EDT
Question: Had an interesting occurance today.Utility had a tree fall on thier transmission line. A building being served by this utility caused an input breaker for a UPS to trip downstream from the Main distribution board. The settings and coordination curves are set to have this breaker trip first before the upstream breaker. So it did its job. However, I'm trying to determine why no other breakers tripped in the overall system.With a line to ground or a line to line fault from the utility happens, does a "surge" occur on the line for a few cycles once the fault clears?I don't belieive the facility has surge protection. Has anyone seen this before?Thanks!
Current Interruption and Voltage Surges
When a fault occurs on a transmission line, a large amount of current flows through the fault path. This current is interrupted by protective devices, such as circuit breakers or fuses, to prevent damage to equipment and infrastructure.The interruption of current creates a sudden change in the voltage on the line. This change in voltage can result in a voltage surge, which is a momentary increase in voltage above the normal operating level.
Why No Other Breakers Tripped
In your case, it is possible that the voltage surge from the utility fault was not sufficient to trip any other breakers in the system. This could be due to several factors: High Impedance Path
The path from the point of fault to the other breakers may have had a high impedance, limiting the surge current.
Slow Response Time
The breakers may have had a slower response time to voltage surges compared to the UPS input breaker.
Coordination Settings
The breakers were likely coordinated to trip in a specific sequence, with the UPS input breaker having the lowest pickup setting.
Surge Protection
Surge protection devices (SPDs) are designed to protect equipment from voltage surges. They typically consist of surge arresters or transient voltage suppressors (TVSs) that conduct excess voltage to ground.In your case, it is possible that the facility does not have surge protection, or that the surge protection was not effective in this instance.
Conclusion
It is likely that the voltage surge from the utility fault was not sufficient to trip any other breakers in the system due to high impedance, slow response time, or coordination settings. It is also possible that the facility does not have adequate surge protection.To prevent similar issues in the future, consider the following: Review the coordination settings of protective devices to ensure they are appropriate for the system configuration.* Install surge protection devices at critical points in the system, such as the main distribution board. Flag for review