User: sii, Location: Nebraska
Asked on: Friday, February 25, 2011 at 8:30 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:05 am EDT
Question: Just as I was leaving today I got an email saying that I am to escort a representative from Utiliguard through our plant on Monday morning. They are pitching "a device that takes electrical spikes and moves the excess to ground" and "the potential to save us 15 -20% of our energy costs." I'm guessing a TVSS for the first claim and PFC for the second claim. Quotes are from an email forwarded directly from the rep.My extremely limited understanding of PFC from a class I took a long time ago is that it can only save you money if your POCO has a power factor charge. Their site claims to reduce the KWH on your bill, I can't see how that's possible.My main concern is that the VP of Operations, who originally contacted this company is the kind of guy that once he gets an idea in his head, you cannot convince him otherwise (it took me four years to convince him that just because his garage has three wire that doesn't mean he has three-phase power). I'm going to try to be open-minded regarding this, although my default is usually skepticism...I don't want to go into this with an unjustified negative opinion.Most of this stuff is a little above my pay grade so I'm looking for some guidance to assist me in being able to have a constructive conversation with this rep. I'm also curious to see if anyone here has dealt with this company directly.Link to site: http://www.utiliguard.com/TIA
Understanding the Claims TVSS (Transient Voltage Surge Suppressor)
This device protects against electrical spikes and surges that can damage equipment. While it can improve equipment safety, it does not directly save energy.
PFC (Power Factor Correction)
PFC devices can improve the efficiency of electrical systems by reducing the reactive power flowing through the system. This can reduce energy costs if the utility charges for power factor. However, it's important to note that PFC does not reduce KWH consumption.
Assessing the Rep's Claims Question the 15-20% energy savings claim
Request data or case studies to support this claim and inquire about possible utility charges that may affect the savings.
Clarify the "reduced KWH" claim
Ask the rep to explain how their device can reduce KWH consumption, considering that PFC only affects reactive power.
Determine if your utility charges for power factor
Contact your utility to confirm whether they have a power factor penalty or incentive program. If not, PFC may not provide significant savings.
Preparing for the Meeting Review the Utiliguard website
Gather information about their products and claims.
Research PFC and TVSS
Gain a basic understanding of the technologies and their potential benefits.
Be open-minded
Approach the meeting with a willingness to consider the rep's claims, but maintain a critical perspective.
Ask specific questions
Prepare questions to address the energy savings claims, power factor charges, and any technical details that you don't understand.
Seek independent verification
Consider consulting with an electrical engineer or energy consultant to provide an unbiased opinion.
Guidance for a Constructive Conversation Welcome the rep
Express interest in learning about their products.
State your concerns
Clearly outline your understanding of PFC and TVSS, and express any doubts you have about the energy savings claims.
Ask probing questions
Seek clarification and evidence to support the rep's claims.
Discuss utility charges
Inquire about the utility's power factor charges and whether they may impact the savings.
Request data and case studies
Ask the rep to provide data or examples to demonstrate the effectiveness of their devices.
Consider an independent evaluation
Suggest the involvement of an external expert to assess the validity of the claims.*
Follow up
Summarize the key points of the meeting and request additional information as needed.
Note: I have not dealt with Utiliguard directly, so I cannot provide any specific insights about their company. Flag for review