User: G._S._Ohm, Location: DC area
Asked on: Sunday, February 27, 2011 at 11:54 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:08 am EDT
Question: Laws are written vaguely and this is necessary to limit the total number of laws.Lawyers depend on caselaw, which is sometimes contradictory, to decide the literal meaning of a law for the case in front of them at the moment.Bad laws occasionally get repealed.The NEC is written very densely and abstractly, in places.Electricians have to interpret the literal meaning of the rules for the installation in front of them at the moment.Is there a parallel for caselaw for electricians?What does it take to get a "bad" rule deleted from the NEC?Do "good" rules occasionally get deleted from the NEC, by accident or on purpose?Thanks for whatever comments you can provide me.
Parallel for Case Law for Electricians
Yes, there is a parallel for case law for electricians. It is called interpretation guidelines. These guidelines provide interpretations of NEC rules and are issued by the NEC Code-Making Panel (CMP). They are published in the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Journal and are considered authoritative sources for electrical installation practices.
Process for Deleting a "Bad" Rule from the NEC
To get a "bad" rule deleted from the NEC, the following process is generally followed:1. Submit a proposal
A person or organization must submit a proposal to the CMP to delete the rule.2.
Public review and comment
The proposal is published for public review and comment.3.
CMP action
The CMP reviews the proposal and comments. They may accept, reject, or modify the proposal.4.
NFPA Voting Process
If the CMP accepts the proposal, it is included in the proposed revisions to the NEC. These revisions are then subject to a vote by the NFPA membership.5.
Approval
If the proposed revisions are approved by the NFPA membership, they become part of the next edition of the NEC.
Accidental or Intentional Deletion of "Good" Rules
It is possible for "good" rules to be deleted from the NEC, either accidentally or intentionally. Accidental deletion
This can occur when a rule is inadvertently omitted or replaced during the revision process.
Intentional deletion: This can occur when a rule is determined to be unnecessary, obsolete, or inconsistent with other rules.To prevent accidental deletions, the CMP follows a strict review process. Intentional deletions are made after careful consideration and typically involve input from industry experts and stakeholders. Flag for review