Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Value Engineering

User: CircleG22, Location: Lockport, IL

Asked on: Tuesday, March 1, 2011 at 4:08 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:13 am EDT

Question: This may be more rant than question, but it has happened twice in the past month and would appreciate some feedback on this issue. On one tenant finish bid I noticed that the lighting specs were for all high dollar fixtures. Knowing the owner, I was pretty sure he didn't know what they were asking for. I gave him an alternate lighting price with a savings over $5000.00 for a 3200 sq ft office space. After the bid date he contacted my competition, told him my lighting price, and had him rebid. On the other job the engineer spec'd CU for the service lateral and panel feeders. Because of the recent increase in prices and the fact that the panels feeders did not have heavy loads I asked the engineer if it was OK to bid AL. She OK'd the alternate. I checked with the owner the next week to see how our bid looked and he informed me that he was waiting on the other bids. I then found out he had contacted my competion and had them bid AL. I'm feeling a bit burned. I went out of my way to find savings for the customer (and give myself an advantage) and as a result I was rewarded by having the projects go to someone else who made no effort. Am I justified in feeling I have a right to bill these customers for value engineering or not. I would really appreciate some thoughts on this. The economy is tough enough as it is. Can anyone tell me of a way to protect myself in bidding projects without alerting everyone to various alternates. Thanks,

Justification for Feeling Burned

You are justified in feeling burned because: You invested time and effort in finding cost-saving alternatives. The customers used your information to their advantage, asking your competitors to submit lower bids without giving you the opportunity to adjust your own. This undercut your competitive advantage and potentially cost you business.

Protection Against Similar Situations

To protect yourself in the future, consider the following strategies:
Protect your ideas

Avoid sharing your alternate proposals with customers until you have a firm commitment or contract in place.

State your terms

Include a clause in your bid proposals that disallows customers from soliciting bids based on your alternates without your consent.


Educate customers

Explain to customers the value of your value engineering services before bidding the project. Emphasize the potential savings they can achieve by working with you.

Quantify your savings

Provide detailed breakdowns of the cost savings associated with your alternates. This helps customers understand the value you bring.


Build relationships

Establish strong relationships with your customers. This will make them more likely to value your expertise and avoid using your ideas against you.

Billing for Value Engineering


Billing for value engineering is generally not considered ethical or customary in the construction industry. However, you may consider exploring: Charging for additional services

If you provide detailed analysis or documentation of your alternates, you could consider charging for those services.


Negotiating a higher contract price

If you can demonstrate the value of your alternates and the customer is willing to pay more for them, you can negotiate a higher contract price.

Additional Tips
Be careful about revealing too much information on specs in your bids. Consider providing a range of options to give the customer flexibility.* Foster a collaborative relationship with the engineer and owner where you can discuss value engineering ideas openly. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question