User: kbsparky, Location: Delmarva, USA
Asked on: Wednesday, March 2, 2011 at 12:53 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:14 am EDT
Question: I am involved in a project where a new detached building is being constructed in the parking lot of an existing complex. This new building will be a garage-type structure, mainly used to protect vehicles from the weather. The entire complex is under single management.There was an electrical conduit installed under the parking lot in anticipation of this new building, so new electrical feeder cables could be installed.Now that the new building is under construction, the management wants to know if I can install a phone cable in the same conduit as the feeder wires, and also a cable for some fire alarm sensors.My first instinct here is to say "no" -- they need separate conduit(s) for these things. But adding extra conduits at this point would be a very expensive procedure, since the area is already paved over with concrete.Upon reading the NEC, it appears that IF those extra cables are rated for at least the same or higher voltage as the feeder conductors, then it would be acceptable to do so. (IF those same wires were direct-buried, they would all be allowed to be in the same trench together.)The underground conduit is 4" PVC, and the new building has a 200 Amp service, so there is plenty of room for a couple of extra small cables in there.What is your opinion on this?
NEC Requirements
According to the National Electrical Code (NEC), Article 300.3(C), different types of cables (power, communication, fire alarm) are generally required to be installed in separate conduits. However, there is an exception in Article 300.3(C)(1) that allows multiple cables to be installed in the same conduit if they are all rated for the highest voltage present and the conduit has sufficient space for the additional cables.
Considerations
In your case, the phone cable and fire alarm sensor cable could be installed in the same conduit with the feeder wires, provided that: The phone cable and fire alarm sensor cable are rated for at least 200 volts (the voltage of the feeder wires). The 4" PVC conduit has sufficient space for the additional cables without exceeding the fill capacity (typically 40%).
Additional Factors
In addition to the NEC requirements, there are other factors to consider: Electromagnetic Interference (EMI)
Running different types of cables in the same conduit can create EMI, which can disrupt signals transmitted through the cables.
Grounding
The phone cable and fire alarm sensor cable may have different grounding requirements than the feeder wires, which can be problematic if they are installed in the same conduit.
Future Expansion
If you anticipate adding additional cables in the future, installing separate conduits now would be more cost-effective in the long run.
Recommendation
Based on the factors above, it is generally recommended to install separate conduits for the phone cable and fire alarm sensor cable, even if the NEC allows them to be installed in the same conduit.
Alternative Solutions
If installing separate conduits is not feasible, you could explore alternative solutions such as: Shielding
Shielding the phone cable and fire alarm sensor cable can reduce EMI.
Using Communication-Rated Conduit
Installing these cables in a conduit specifically designed for communication cables can minimize EMI.
Physical Separation: Installing the cables in different sections of the conduit can provide some level of isolation between them. Flag for review