Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: An Acceptable Method for Live >50V Work?

User: HumbleMan, Location: WI

Asked on: Thursday, March 3, 2011 at 12:05 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:18 am EDT

Question: Looking for some opinions on the following scenario.I sometimes have to troubleshoot controls on older equipment where the control voltage is >50V, typically 120VAC on 480V powered units. Our location's live work policy meets 70E, no live work unless it's approved by the plant manager and you filed the appropriate paperwork and he usually says "no".The troubleshooting iteration typically is to power off, LOTO, add probes to likely points to locate the problem, close the door, re-energize and see if you guessed correctly where to place the probe points.Per the standard:NFPA 70E Article 130.1 Justification for work. Live parts to which an employee might be exposed shall be put into an electrically safe work condition before an employee works on or near them, unless the employer can demonstrate that deenergizing introduces additional or increased hazards or is infeasible due to equipment design or operational limitations.What if:1) The main power remains under LOTO so there is no chance for Shock, Flash, or Boom.2) The control power supply is disconnected from the stepdown transformer where it normally supplies the 120VAC. (No backfeeding to the primary of the transformer.)3) A separate source of 120VAC is used and run through a GFCI outlet or breaker and is then used to power the 120VAC control circuit.Since a GFCI by its nature limits current flow to around 5mA within 25 ms prior to tripping, wouldn't this "put into an electrically safe work condition" the equipment so that the control functionality could be tested live?Additionally, do you think a "Live Work Request" needs to be filed each time this is done?

Regarding the safety of the proposed procedure



Using a separate 120VAC source

This isolates the control circuit from the high-voltage power supply, eliminating the risk of shock or flash from the primary side.


GFCI protection

The GFCI limits current flow to a safe level, providing protection against electrical hazards in case of a fault.Based on these measures, it is reasonable to argue that the equipment can be considered "electrically safe" for the purpose of live troubleshooting. However, it is important to consider the following:

Potential for induced voltage

Even with the main power disconnected, there is a small possibility of induced voltage on the control circuit due to electromagnetic coupling with the high-voltage power lines. This can still be a hazard if not properly mitigated.


Compliance with NFPA 70E

Article 130.1 of NFPA 70E generally requires de-energization unless it is infeasible or introduces additional hazards. While the proposed procedure addresses the risks of shock and flash, it may not be considered "infeasible" to de-energize the control circuit.

Regarding the need for a Live Work Request

If the proposed procedure is deemed safe and compliant with NFPA 70E, a Live Work Request may not be necessary. However, it is always good practice to consult with a qualified electrical safety professional and obtain approval before performing live work.

Recommendations:
Conduct a thorough risk assessment to evaluate the potential hazards and mitigate them accordingly. Consider factors such as induced voltage, accessibility of the control circuit, and the experience and training of the personnel involved. Consult with an electrical safety professional to determine if de-energizing the control circuit is infeasible or introduces additional hazards. If live work is deemed necessary, establish clear procedures and require appropriate training for personnel. Consider using a second qualified person to monitor the situation. Document the risk assessment and any approvals obtained before proceeding with live work. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question