User: jhammer619, Location: Mission Viejo, CA
Asked on: Thursday, March 3, 2011 at 12:14 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:18 am EDT
Question: Hello everyone,The NEC says that the Zone system is "an alternative" to the Division system. Does this mean an American electrical designer truly has the choice of which system he uses to classify a hazardous location on a drawing? Or is it implied (preferred?) that he will be using the Division system since he is designing an American facility. If so, why is the zone system included in the NEC? For reference?Can an electrical designer use both? (Similar to using both Feet and Meters, for crude comparison.)Sorry if I missed a previous thread discussing the same topic. Please refer me if I did.Thanks in advance,-J
The NEC does not state that the Zone system is an "alternative" to the Division system. It states that it is an "equivalent" system, meaning that it provides the same level of safety as the Division system.In the US, the Division system is more commonly used than the Zone system. However, the Zone system is becoming more popular, especially in international applications.There are a few reasons why an electrical designer might choose to use the Zone system instead of the Division system:- The Zone system is more flexible than the Division system. It allows for a wider range of hazardous materials and conditions to be classified.- The Zone system is more international. It is the preferred system in many countries around the world.- The Zone system is easier to understand than the Division system. It uses a simpler set of rules and regulations.An electrical designer can use both the Division system and the Zone system on a drawing. However, it is important to be consistent with the use of the two systems. Do not mix and match the two systems on the same drawing.Here is a link to a previous thread that discusses the same topic:https://www.electrical-contractor.net/threads/zone-vs-division-for-class-i-ii-iii.8422/ Flag for review