User: charlie b, Location: Lockport, IL
Asked on: Thursday, March 3, 2011 at 5:50 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:19 am EDT
Question: Existing building being renovated. Existing utility transformer and (I believe) utility-owned service conductors. Thus, the utility-owner transition would be the lugs of the main breaker on the main service panel. That panel is rated 800 amps, and the main breaker is 800 amps. Let us assume a calculated load of 600 amps.My information is that the service conductors are (2) sets of 500 MCM Aluminum. That has an ampacity of 620. Under NEC rules, you can?t protect a 620 amp conductor set with an 800 amp breaker (i.e., next higher standard size is 700). Furthermore, you can?t take advantage of the ?next higher standard rating? rule in 240.4(B) for transformer secondary conductors. So the breaker has to be 600 or lower.Here?s the question: Is this something I can ignore, given that the service conductors belong to the utility? Or is it the responsibility of the owner (whose interests are to be safeguarded by the design engineer ? myself) to ensure that the main breaker is capable of protecting the service conductors in accordance with NEC rules? Specifically, should I call for a design change to replace or reset the breaker to a maximum trip of 600 amps?
Responsibility for Protection of Utility-Owned Service Conductors
The National Electrical Code (NEC) requires that electrical equipment be protected from overcurrent conditions. This includes the protection of service conductors, regardless of ownership.In the scenario you described, the service conductors are owned by the utility. However, the property owner remains responsible for the electrical system within their building, including the main breaker.
NEC Requirements for Protection of Service Conductors
NEC Article 240.4(B) states that overcurrent protection devices (OCPDs) for transformer secondary conductors (e.g., service conductors) shall be rated not less than the ampacity of the conductors.In your case, the service conductors have an ampacity of 620 amps. Therefore, the main breaker must be rated at a maximum of 620 amps to provide adequate protection.
Your Options
Given the discrepancy between the ampacity of the service conductors and the rating of the main breaker, you have two options:1. Call for a Design Change
- Require the replacement or resetting of the main breaker to a maximum trip setting of 600 amps or less. This will ensure compliance with NEC requirements for protecting the service conductors.2.
Consult with the Utility
- Discuss the situation with the utility and obtain their guidance. They may have specific requirements or exceptions that apply to their service equipment.
Recommendation
It is generally advisable to follow NEC requirements and ensure that the main breaker is appropriately rated to protect the service conductors. This helps to mitigate potential safety hazards and ensures that the electrical system operates reliably.Therefore, it is recommended to call for a design change to replace or reset the main breaker to a maximum trip setting of 600 amps or less. Flag for review