Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Feeder taps 240.21(B)

User: goldstar, Location: New Jersey

Asked on: Friday, March 4, 2011 at 8:02 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:20 am EDT

Question: Went on a service call yesterday after receiving a call from a plumbing contractor that do work for. On the phone he explained that he was at a customers house where an instant hot water unit was installed by someone else and he was there testing to see what the hot water recovery time was, After bleeding the system of hot water about 10 minutes went by and then the sound of an explosion from the basement came. When he went down to see what the problem was he saw a sub-panel that went from gray to charcoal.I went out to investigate and found the foillowing:There were two main lug panels; one was a 30 circuit SQ-D QO completely loaded the other was a 20 circuitInside the 20 circuit panel were (2) 2-pole 30 amp breakers, (1) 15 amp 2-pole breaker and several 20 amp breakersthe EC who installed the electric for the water heaters installed (2) 2-pole 50 amp breakers to feed the unitNow, here's the problem, the feeder for both panels comes from a 300 amp main breaker that's about 20' away. The feeder is 350 KCM (underground) into a trough above the panels. Tapped on to the 350KCM are (3) 4/0 AL for the 30 circuit panel and #4's AL for the 20 circuit panel. Prior to this EC adding the two 50 amp breakers to the panel fed with #4's, the panels held and there were no problems. With respect to feeder taps and prior to the addition of the two 50 amp breakers was this a ligit tap installation ? The tap was less than 3'.Long story-short, the #4's burnt up and separated inside the nipple to the trough. The 350's are still in tact and un-damaged.If I'm called in to make the correction to this system IMHO, and from the standpoint of safety, I would install two 150 amp main breaker panels and re-make the taps in the trough. I would be using the 150 amp main breakers both as overload protection and for safety and convenience. Neutrals would float and EGC's bonded to the enclosure. Am I wrong or is this over-kill ?

Legality of the Previous Tap Installation

Based on the information provided, the previous tap installation was not compliant with the National Electrical Code (NEC). The tap for the #4 AL feeders was too close to the main breaker (less than 3'). NEC requires a minimum tap distance of 24" from the main breaker or service overcurrent device (Article 310.15(B)(2)).

Your Proposed Correction

Your proposed correction is generally safe and compliant with the NEC. However, it is important to consider the following: Panel Capacity

150 amp main breakers are typically used for panels with a capacity of 125 amps or more. If the 20-circuit panel was not originally rated for 125 amps, it may not be suitable for a 150 amp main breaker.


Load Calculations

Ensure that all loads on both panels are calculated and the total load does not exceed the capacity of the main breakers.

Feeder Sizing

The 350 kcmil feeder is likely sufficient for the calculated load. However, verify that it meets the minimum ampacity requirements based on the total load and the distance to the main breaker.

Overkill or Safety Precaution?


Your proposed correction is not overkill from a safety standpoint. In fact, it provides a higher level of safety by:
Separating the circuits into two independent panels, reducing the risk of cascading faults. Using 150 amp main breakers for overload protection and safety shutoff. Installing new taps that comply with NEC requirements.However, it is important to consider the cost and feasibility of installing two new panels versus modifying the existing installation. If the existing panels are in good condition and the taps can be safely relocated, that may be a more economical option.

Recommendation

Ultimately, the best course of action will depend on the specific circumstances and should be determined by a qualified electrician. They will be able to assess the situation, perform the necessary calculations, and recommend the most appropriate and safe solution. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question