Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Different manufacture?s crimp lugs on parallel feeders?

User: MEP_PM, Location: MA

Asked on: Saturday, March 5, 2011 at 3:03 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:23 am EDT

Question: On a job with 4 sets of parallel 600MCM feeders, the equipment manufacture did not supply enough crimp on lugs to finish the installation. The lugs that are readily available are made by a different manufacture. Do you see a problem with allowing a different manufacture's lug to be installed? Or would there be a concern this would change the overall resistance and cause an imbalance in conductors? New lugs that match will be ordered to ensure there isn?t a problem but I thought it was an interesting question. Thoughts?

Potential Concerns with Mixing Lug Manufacturers



Compatibility

Different manufacturers' lugs may have different dimensions, which could affect their ability to mate properly with the feeders and busbars.


Material Properties

Lugs from different manufacturers may be made of different materials with varying conductivity, which could create an imbalance in resistance.

Certifications

If the original lug manufacturer's lugs had specific certifications (e.g., UL Listed), mixing in lugs from a different manufacturer may void those certifications.


Long-Term Reliability

Over time, dissimilar lugs may exhibit different thermal and mechanical properties, which could lead to potential issues such as loosening connections or overheating.

Recommended Approach

It is generally not recommended to mix lug manufacturers on the same conductor due to the potential concerns listed above. It is best to order the original lug manufacturer's lugs to ensure compatibility and avoid potential problems. If mixing lugs is unavoidable, the following precautions should be taken: Verify that the different lugs are compatible in terms of dimensions and material properties. Use a torque wrench to ensure that all lugs are tightened to the manufacturer's specifications. Monitor the installation closely for any signs of overheating or loose connections.* Document the use of different lugs in the job documentation for future reference.

Note:
The overall resistance of the feeders is unlikely to be significantly affected by using a different lug manufacturer, as long as the lugs are compatible and installed properly. However, the potential for long-term problems should be carefully considered. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question