Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Sizing a 3 Phase Breaker when multiple single phase loads are connected Line to Line

User: Harold H, Location: Ohio

Asked on: Saturday, March 5, 2011 at 7:43 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:23 am EDT

Question: Here is the problem.... at least it's my problem:4 single phase heater loads are connected line to line on a 3 Phase 240VAC feed. They are arranged as follows:4 amp load connected across phase A and B5 amp load connected across phase B and C11 amp load connected across phase C and A13 amp load connected across phase B and AWhat is maximum current in any leg so I can size the required 3 phase circuit breaker to protect the wiring for the entire group of loads?I've searched the forums all over the web and cann't get a clear explanation. I get the 3 phase motor load calcs and the 1 phase calcs, but this line to line single phase current on a 3 phase system is still a head scratcher.To get the currents in each leg, I originally thought I needed to add all the load currents for each phase (4+11+13 for phase A), then I got word to divide this by 1.73 to get the actual current in each leg. The more I think about this, it is not making sense to me, ergo the call for help. I'm not just looking for the "right answer" but the reason why?

Step 1: Convert Line-to-Line Voltages to Line-to-Neutral Voltages

For a 3-phase system, the line-to-line voltage is √3 times the line-to-neutral voltage. In this case, the line-to-line voltage is 240 VAC, so the line-to-neutral voltage is:

V_LN = V_LL / √3= 240 / 1.732≈ 138.5 VAC
Step 2: Calculate Phase Currents

Each heater load draws current only through the phases it is connected to. Therefore, the phase currents are: Phase A: 4 amps + 13 amps = 17 amps Phase B: 13 amps + 5 amps = 18 amps Phase C: 11 amps + 4 amps = 15 ampsStep 3: Determine Maximum Current in Any Leg

The maximum current in any leg will occur when the load currents in that leg are at their peak and in phase. This happens when the loads are at their highest power consumption.Since the loads are purely resistive, their power factor (PF) is 1. Therefore, the current and voltage are in phase.The current in each leg is the vector sum of the phase currents that flow through that leg. For example, the current in leg A is:
I_A = √(4^2 + 13^2)≈ 13.9 amps
Similarly, we can calculate the currents in legs B and C:
I_B ≈ 13.9 amps* I_C ≈ 13.9 ampsConclusion

The maximum current in any leg is approximately 13.9 amps. Therefore, a 3-phase circuit breaker rated for at least 13.9 amps is required to protect the wiring for this group of loads.

Reason for Division by 1.73:


The division by 1.73 (which is the square root of 3) is incorrect in this case because the line-to-neutral voltage, not the line-to-line voltage, is used to calculate the phase currents. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question