User: scauri, Location: Tennessee
Asked on: Sunday, March 6, 2011 at 9:57 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:24 am EDT
Question: Never had this problem till" NOw.In n.j.only!210.4 B states:each multiwire branch circuitshall be simultaneusly disconnected with all other corrisponding breakers!?please read it and let me know how you interprete it.Am, having a very hard time with it.Up to now,in 40 years of knowlrdge,I have always put single breakers ,# different phases and aneutral feeding 3 different 120v circuits:lights and or recepticals.Only exeption{exibit 210.1 and 210.2},wich i can agree with.Had installed a 277 for lighting only as well as 2 thre phases panels feeding lights and recepticals,besides 3 phase motors.According to a n.j.inspector ,I had to replace single pole breakesTo double or triple breakers because i was using three ,or two hot legs with a neutral.Or install breaker ties!Absurd!As far back as i can remember we always installed 12-2 romex feeing two circuits in kitche ,three phase with a neutral etc.I bet you 100 % of all building work has been done that way in the past.Do you know how much money is involved if we now have to change this practic?Single neutral for each circuit ,or breaker ties?It is not practical and not right!What cvan we do to change this?Please get back.The last job almost put me out of business because of this!
Interpretation of 210.4 B210.4 B of the National Electrical Code (NEC) states:> "Each multiwire branch circuit shall be simultaneously disconnected with all other corresponding breakers."This means that all hot conductors (phase wires) and the neutral conductor of a multiwire branch circuit must be disconnected simultaneously. This is typically accomplished by using a single multi-pole circuit breaker (e.g., a double or triple breaker) or by using a combination of single-pole and multi-pole circuit breakers with handle ties.
Traditional Practice vs. NEC Requirement
Historically, it has been common practice to use single-pole breakers on different phases to feed three different 120V circuits with a shared neutral. However, this practice is now prohibited by 210.4 B in New Jersey.
Reasons for the Change
The NEC requires simultaneous disconnection of multiwire branch circuits for safety reasons. In a multiwire branch circuit, a fault on one phase conductor can cause overvoltages on the other phase conductors, which can pose a shock hazard. Simultaneous disconnection ensures that all phase conductors are de-energized, protecting against this hazard.
Implications for Existing Installations
Existing installations that do not comply with 210.4 B may be required to be brought up to code. This could involve replacing single-pole breakers with multi-pole breakers or installing breaker ties.
Options for Compliance
To comply with 210.4 B, you can: Use multi-pole circuit breakers
Install a single multi-pole circuit breaker to protect all hot and neutral conductors of the multiwire branch circuit.
Use single-pole breakers with handle ties
Install single-pole breakers on different phases and use handle ties to ensure that they are operated simultaneously.*
Install separate neutral conductors
Use a separate neutral conductor for each circuit, rather than sharing a neutral among multiple circuits.
Call to Action
If you are concerned about the implications of 210.4 B, you should contact a qualified electrician for guidance. They can evaluate your existing installations and recommend the most appropriate solutions for bringing them up to code. It is also important to work with local electrical inspectors to ensure that your installations meet all applicable requirements. Flag for review