User: clarkwg, Location: Henrico County, VA
Asked on: Monday, March 7, 2011 at 11:22 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:27 am EDT
Question: Ok bear with me this is a long explanation of what I tried to figure out today.Customer called on Friday and stated that they were testing elevator recalls and such in a 34 story building in Seattle.They were in one cab and switched off the cab lights with the keyed switch in the cab and 3- 1pole 20 amp gfci breakers tripped in the sub panel feeding all the 8 elevator car cab lights ( 3 phase 60 amp 120/208 sub panel with 8- 1 pole 20 amp gfci breakers , 1 for each elevator car .) the three that tripped were all on one phase. The elevator tech pulled the switch and capped off the hot ,reset the other two breakers and tried resetting the breaker for the car they were working on.All three breakers tripped again. Put switch back together turned it back on , reset all breakers and they stayed on .When I showed up this morning we turned keyed switch off , all three breakers tripped.Turned switch on,reset all three breakers ,started pulling the compact flourescent lamps out one at a time .( 8 -can lights ,6 have 5 watt lamps , 2 have 14 watt lamps. ) pulled all 5 watt lamps, got to one of the 14 watt,pulled it and all three breakers tripped again. put the 14 watt lamp in different can light, reset breakers , pulled the 14 watt lamp again ,breakers tripped again.Tried various combinations of lamps and without any lamps installed , breakers trip without at least one of the 14 watt lamps installed. Can't isolate the problem to any 1 can light.Tried shutting off the keyed switches and pulling lamps in the other two cars that kept tripping , no tripping .
Possible Causes
Faulty 14-watt Lamp
The 14-watt lamp may have an internal fault that is causing a ground fault when it is installed.
Mismatched Lamp Types
The combination of 5-watt and 14-watt lamps in the same circuit may be causing an imbalance in the current flow and triggering the GFCIs.
Electrical Defect in Light Fixture
One of the can lights may have a damaged wiring connection or component that is causing the ground fault.
Neutral Wire Issue
The neutral wire may be improperly connected or have a loose connection, causing current to flow through the ground wire and tripping the GFCIs.*
Subpanel Overload
The 60-amp subpanel may be overloaded, causing the GFCIs to trip when additional load is added from the 14-watt lamps.
Troubleshooting Steps
1.
Isolate the Faulty Lamp
Try replacing the 14-watt lamp with a new one. If the breakers still trip, the lamp is likely faulty.2.
Test with Single Lamp Type
Remove all the 5-watt lamps and replace them with 14-watt lamps (or vice versa). See if the breakers trip with only one type of lamp installed.3.
Inspect Light Fixtures
Carefully inspect the wiring connections and components of all the can lights. Look for any signs of damage or loose connections.4.
Check Neutral Wire
Ensure that the neutral wire is properly connected at the subpanel and all light fixtures. Tighten any loose connections.5.
Monitor Subpanel Load: Use an ammeter to monitor the current flow in the subpanel. If the current exceeds the subpanel's capacity, consider reducing the number of lamps or installing a larger subpanel.If the problem persists after following these steps, it may be necessary to call a qualified electrician to further diagnose and repair the issue. Flag for review