User: ElectricianJeff, Location: Southern Illinois
Asked on: Tuesday, March 8, 2011 at 10:39 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:28 am EDT
Question: I have a job this Friday that has me second guessing myself. This is in an area that I don't do alot of work in and I am not familiar with the inspector. This is a result of a city inspection do to a change in occupancy and I am getting my information second hand from the homeowner.This is a 100 amp. push-matic split bus panel. The two 50 amp. mains are located in the middle of the bus. The inspector has a problem with the fact that 2 different breakers have to be pushed to disconnect power. In reviewing 230.71 and 230.72 ('05) this existing installation meets my interpretation of these sections.I will be installing a 100 amp exterior disconnect since the meter base is about 15' from this panel.According to the HO the inspector wants a plate attached to these 2 breakers to allow the service to be disconnected with just one push. My thinking is that the field modification of this existing panel is more of a code issue than what presently exists.I would be interested in any input on this in case I am missing something.
Interpretation of NEC
You are correct in your interpretation of NEC 230.71 and 230.72 (2005). These sections do not require a single-pole disconnect for a split bus panel.
Inspector's Concern
The inspector's concern is likely based on the safety issue of having to manually operate two breakers to disconnect power in an emergency. However, the NEC does not explicitly address this concern.
Field Modification
Modifying the panel by adding a plate to connect the two breakers would create a new code violation.
Recommended Course of Action1. Communicate with the Inspector
Discuss your interpretation of the NEC with the inspector and explain your concerns about modifying the panel.2.
Propose a Solution
Offer to install an exterior disconnect, which would provide a single point of disconnection for the service.3.
Appeal the Decision
If the inspector is unwilling to accept your interpretation, you may consider appealing the decision to the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ).
Additional Considerations Panel Labeling
Ensure that the panel is properly labeled to indicate that it is a split bus panel and that two breakers must be turned off to disconnect power.
Safety Precautions
Emphasize to the homeowner the importance of always turning off both breakers when servicing the electrical system.
Conclusion
The existing split bus panel installation meets the NEC requirements. While the inspector's concern is valid, field modification of the panel is not the appropriate solution. Installing an exterior disconnect would provide a safer and code-compliant method of disconnecting the service. Flag for review