User: cestone, Location: here
Asked on: Tuesday, March 8, 2011 at 12:12 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:29 am EDT
Question: I have been an electrical designer for 20 years. I am using the 2008 NEC for my design. I thought I had a firm grasp of the fire pump code, but when my project manager contacted a previous designer for his opinion, I can no longer rely on my interpretation of the code based upon what he was told by the previous employee. I have been reading all sorts of forums on Fire Pump electrical installations lately trying to make some sense of what I am being told.I have been designing the normal/emergency service feed to the fire pump from an ATS underground to the Fire Pump Control panel. The ATS also serves other emergency loads by a distribution panel to emergency branch panels. I have a stand-by Generator feeding the emergency side of the ATS.I am being told that the NEC requires a breaker between the power source and the fire pump control panel and that breaker should only be for short-circuit protection. I have information from Sq D that states if the Fire Pump is fed by a service, the circuit breaker is sized to carry the LRA indefinitely. Where a generator serves the fire pump, the NEC allows me to use Table 430.52 instead of setting the breaker at LRA. Table 430.52 sizes the breaker at a max. of 250% of the motor. In my design, I have both.The fire pump is a 20HP 208volt 3 phase motor. It has always been my understanding that the NEC prefers no breaker between the source (utility or stand-by generator) and the fire pump control panel.Can someone shed some light on this situation for me?Thank you so much for your help
NEC Requirements Article 430.52 states that the feeder to the fire pump controller shall be protected by an overcurrent protective device rated not less than 115% of the full-load current of the fire pump. Article 445.11(C)(1) states that the service-entrance conductors supplying the fire pump shall be protected by an overcurrent device rated not less than 115% of the nameplate full-load current of the fire pump. Exception No. 1 to 445.11(C)(1)
Where the fire pump supply is from the load side of a circuit breaker feeder serving also the normal lighting and appliance load (other than the fire pump motor), the overcurrent protective device protecting the fire pump supply shall be rated at not less than 100% of the nameplate full-load current of the fire pump motor.
Breaker Sizing For services supplying only the fire pump, the breaker must be sized for 115% of the full-load current (FLC). For feeders from generators supplying only the fire pump, Table 430.52 allows for a breaker sized up to 250% of the FLC. For services or feeders supplying both the fire pump and other loads, the breaker can be sized for 100% of the FLC if the fire pump is sized for at least 100 kW (Article 445.11(C)(1), Exception No. 1).
Requirements for No Breaker
The NEC does not require a breaker between the source and the fire pump controller in the following cases: Where the fire pump is supplied by a separate service that has no other loads than the fire pump (Article 445.11(C)). Where the fire pump is supplied by a feeder from a dedicated generator that has no other loads than the fire pump (Article 430.53).
Your Design
In your case, you have both a service and a generator feeding the fire pump. Therefore, you must have a breaker between the power source and the fire pump control panel. The breaker should be sized for 100% of the FLC since the fire pump is less than 100 kW.
Conclusion
Your interpretation of the code was correct that the NEC prefers no breaker between the source and the fire pump control panel when possible. However, in your case, you need a breaker due to the presence of both a service and a generator feeding the fire pump. Flag for review