Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: contactors & relays

User: bigjer, Location: riverton ut.

Asked on: Tuesday, March 8, 2011 at 5:05 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:30 am EDT

Question: I couldn't find a topic comparison so here it is.i've got a 240 volt heat tape circuit 250' long maxed out on a 20 amp epd controlled by a eti snow sensor. Snow sensor is tied to the coil at 120volts to pull in a contactor 40amps resistive,using a seperate circuit thru the sensor to avoid problems with inrush.This is a field constructed control one of many ive put togeather some worked well & some notthe problem i have is that the contactor at some point will not stay closed & begin to rattle & make a huge racket. can someone help me with my design problemthe wireing is all in # 12 thhn.

Topic ComparisonTopic 1: Heat Tape Control Circuit 240 volt heat tape circuit 250' long Maxed out on a 20 amp EPD Controlled by a ETI snow sensor Snow sensor tied to coil at 120 volts Contactor 40 amps resistive Separate circuit through sensor to avoid problems with inrushTopic 2: Contactor Not Staying Closed Contactor begins to rattle and make noise Contactor will not stay closedComparison

Both topics relate to a heat tape control circuit that is experiencing issues. Topic 1 provides details about the design and installation of the circuit, while Topic 2 focuses on a specific problem encountered with the contactor.

Potential Problem Causes

Based on the information provided, some potential causes of the contactor not staying closed include:
Overheating

The contactor may be overheating due to excessive current draw or insufficient cooling.

Loose connections

Loose connections in the circuit can cause voltage drops and intermittent contact, leading to the contactor dropping out.


Faulty contactor

The contactor itself may be malfunctioning or have become damaged.

Inrush current

When the contactor is energized, it draws a high inrush current that can momentarily exceed the capacity of the circuit or damage the contactor.

Possible Solutions


To resolve the issue, the following steps can be considered:
Check for overheating

Verify that the circuit is not overloaded and that the contactor is properly cooled.

Inspect connections

Tighten all electrical connections and ensure they are secure.


Test the contactor

Disconnect the contactor and test it separately to determine if it is functioning properly.

Reduce inrush current

Use a soft-start device or limit the inrush current by connecting a resistor in series with the contactor coil.

Additional Considerations
It is important to consult with a qualified electrician for proper installation and troubleshooting of electrical circuits. The circuit should be designed and installed in accordance with electrical codes and safety regulations. Regular maintenance and inspection of the circuit can help prevent problems and ensure reliable operation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question