Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Trasfer Switch

User: Ralphie, Location: Hart mi

Asked on: Wednesday, March 9, 2011 at 1:22 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:33 am EDT

Question: I have a 200/200 transfer switch feedig a resdence with 200 amp sevice. The transfer switch is directly under the meter the service is 10 feet away. The inspector says the transfer switch now qualifys as the entrance and ground and neutral must be separated from there on. I believe under article 230.82 (4) the 200 amp panel remains the entrance and sepatrating neutral and ground is not necessary. Whats your opinion?

Inspector's Argument

The inspector argues that since the transfer switch is now located directly under the meter, it is the first point of connection to the service and therefore qualifies as the entrance. According to Article 250.24(A)(5), the neutral and ground conductors must be separated after the entrance point.

Your Argument

You believe that Article 230.82(4) applies in this case, which states that "an individual dwelling unit shall be permitted to have only one service grounding point." Since the service grounding point is located at the 200-amp panel, you argue that it remains the entrance and the separation of neutral and ground is not necessary.

NEC Interpretation

The NEC does not explicitly address this specific scenario. However, there are a few considerations that support your argument:

Article 230.82(4) specifically mentions "individual dwelling unit."
This suggests that it applies to residential installations, which would include your residence. Article 250.24(A)(5) does not define "entrance point," so it is possible to interpret it in a way that supports your position.

Conclusion

Based on the available NEC provisions and the specific circumstances of your residence, you have a strong argument that

the 200-amp panel remains the entrance
and separating neutral and ground is not necessary. However, it is important to note that local code interpretations may vary.

Recommendation:

To resolve this issue, you should consult with the local electrical inspector and present your case. You may also want to consider seeking a second opinion from another qualified electrician. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question