User: nizak, Location: NC & IN
Asked on: Thursday, March 10, 2011 at 6:22 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:38 am EDT
Question: If I'm reading this correctly, an existing sub feed to a remote building does not require an EGC as long as there is no metallic path between the two structures. I've got a 3 wire 120/240V U.G. feed that I would like to reconnect at the house, that is feeding a pole barn. I've completely rewired the dwelling after it was damaged by fire, and am being told by the AHJ that it has to be a 4 wire to the barn. Not an easy task since it's concrete the entire 125' distance. Do I have a legitimate gripe or am I misinterpreting it. Thanks.
Interpretation of Code Requirement
Section 250.30(A)(5) of the National Electrical Code (NEC) states that an existing subfeed to a remote building does not require an equipment grounding conductor (EGC) if the following conditions are met: There is no metallic path between the two structures. The subfeed is installed in a non-metallic raceway or sheath. The subfeed is not grounded at any point outside the remote building.
Your Situation
Based on your description, your existing subfeed to the pole barn meets the NEC requirements for not requiring an EGC. Specifically: There is no metallic path between the dwelling and the pole barn since the subfeed is underground. You have not mentioned any non-metallic raceway or sheath, but it is assumed that the subfeed was installed in one. You have not mentioned any grounding of the subfeed outside the pole barn.
AHJ's Requirement
The AHJ's requirement for a 4-wire subfeed to the barn may be based on local code interpretations or other safety concerns. It is generally recommended to follow the AHJ's requirements, even if they differ from the NEC.
Legitimate Gripe
You may have a legitimate gripe if the AHJ's requirement is based solely on the NEC and does not consider the existing conditions of your subfeed. However, it is important to discuss this with the AHJ and explain the situation and code requirements to find a mutually acceptable solution.
Possible Solutions: Provide evidence to the AHJ that the existing subfeed meets the NEC requirements for not requiring an EGC. Propose alternative safety measures, such as installing surge protection or ground fault circuit interrupters (GFCIs) at the pole barn.* Explore the possibility of running a new 4-wire subfeed alongside the existing one, if feasible. Flag for review