User: TGE02, Location: California
Asked on: Thursday, March 10, 2011 at 9:04 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:38 am EDT
Question: A buddy of mine owns a building in which he runs a plastic molding injection business out of. He has quite a bit of 3 phase machinery and single phase heating elements that he runs constantly, as well as high bay lighting and some office lighting and what not.The utility transformer is on site and it feeds a 3 phase, 277/480 volt, 600 amp main switch board in his electric room. He has a 145 kva transformer that is fed from his 480 panel that feeds his 120/208 volt panels. Recently the utility transformer blew a fuse, it was replaced. Then the utility transformer stopped working all together and was replaced. The utility company informed him that he will have to pay for their new transformer due to their belief that his 145 kva transformer was the cause of their equipment failure. They gave no explanation as to how or why they believe this to be the cause.Does this sound right? He never had any problems with the breaker tripping on the primary side of the transformer. How would the utility come to this conclusion?Any input is appreciated and I apologize if I posted in the wrong forum. Thanks.
Possible Causes of Utility Transformer Failure
The utility company's belief that the customer's transformer caused the failure of their own transformer is not necessarily valid without further evidence. However, there are a few potential causes that could contribute to transformer failure: Harmonics
Non-linear loads, such as plastic molding injection machines and heating elements, can generate harmonics. Harmonics are electrical distortions that can cause overheating and damage to transformers.
Overloading
If the customer's transformer is overloaded, it can draw excessive current from the utility transformer, causing it to overheat and fail.
Phase Imbalance
An unbalanced load on the customer's transformer can result in excessive current flow in one or two of the phases, stressing the utility transformer.
Capacitor Bank Malfunction
If the customer has a capacitor bank installed to improve power factor, a malfunctioning capacitor can draw excessive current and contribute to transformer failure.
Evidence Required for Liability
To determine if the customer's transformer is responsible for the utility transformer failure, the utility company should provide the following evidence: Inspection Report
An inspection of the failed transformer should be conducted to identify any signs of harmonic distortion, overloading, or other damage.
Meter Data
Data from metering devices installed on the customer's premises can provide information on harmonic levels, current flow, and power factor.
Load Analysis
An analysis of the customer's electrical load can determine if it is appropriate for the size and rating of their transformer.
Customer Options
The customer has the following options if the utility company insists on charging them for the new transformer: Request Independent Inspection
Obtain an independent inspection of the failed transformer to verify the utility company's findings.
Review Meter Data
Analyze the meter data to determine if there is any evidence of overloading or harmonic distortion.
Dispute Liability
Contest the utility company's claim by providing evidence that their own transformer was faulty or that the customer's transformer did not contribute to the failure.*
Negotiate a Settlement: Attempt to negotiate a settlement with the utility company, considering the evidence and the potential costs of a dispute.It is important to note that the utility company should bear the burden of proof to establish that the customer's transformer was the cause of their equipment failure. Flag for review