User: normbac, Location: Ohio
Asked on: Thursday, March 10, 2011 at 11:04 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:38 am EDT
Question: What are the different reasons that some plans call for cb and some are lug only on 3 phase panels with switch gear in same building Reason for question is i have done two TI jobs in same building one required 200 amp with cb. The other required 200 amp main lug only. TIA
Reasons for Circuit Breaker (CB) Panels
Higher fault interrupting capacity
CBs have a higher fault interrupting capacity (FIC) than lug-only panels, meaning they can handle larger fault currents and protect against electrical hazards more effectively.
Safety concerns
CBs automatically trip when an excessive amount of current flows through them, providing a quick and reliable means of isolating faulty circuits.
Convenience
CBs allow for easy troubleshooting and reset of tripped circuits, as they can be simply flipped back on.
Reasons for Lug-Only Panels
Less expensive
Lug-only panels are generally less expensive than CB panels, as they do not contain the additional components of a CB.
Compact size
Lug-only panels are more compact than CB panels, which can be beneficial in space-constrained installations.
Flexibility
Lug-only panels allow for greater flexibility in circuit configuration, as breakers can be added or replaced as needed.
Specific Considerations for 3-Phase Panels with Switchgear
Load characteristics
The load characteristics of the electrical system should be considered. If the system is expected to experience high surge currents or transients, a CB panel may be required for increased protection.
Code requirements
Local electrical codes may require the use of CBs in certain applications, such as main electrical panels.
Maintenance and accessibility
The accessibility of the panel for maintenance and troubleshooting should be taken into account. Lug-only panels may be easier to access and work on.
Preference of the electrician or engineer: The electrician or engineer responsible for the design and installation of the electrical system may have a preference for one type of panel over the other.In your specific case, it's difficult to provide a definitive reason why different panel types were required for the two TI jobs in the same building. It's possible that the differences in load characteristics, code requirements, or other factors influenced the choice of panels. Flag for review