User: ohmhead, Location: ORLANDO FLA
Asked on: Saturday, March 12, 2011 at 9:29 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:43 am EDT
Question: General old cable question 5kv 500 mcm 8 years old testing cable ?Most effective way safe way ?We had a track hoe hit a cable blow out 4160 v cable is 750 feet long .To repair this a splice in a manhole was made one end replaced new and old end remained thur a manhole to the MDP switch to save cost requested by owner .The old cable end was tested with a meg test showed good meaning the old part of that run left in it was asked by engineer not to hi pot this old cable due its age .The new cable now spliced was high potted before splice was made tested good .When we turned on MDP sw we had voltage issues the transformer it was feeding was a step down trans 4160 v to 480 v 3 phase its secondary output was 435v p/p and went down under load p/p 160 volts we shut her down fast .Took off ABC terminations at MDP SW took ohm meter to each phase there was a dead short to its ground foil ground inside cable one[ A ]phase cable .So the megger did not detect this before hand but the engineer would not let us use the hi pot .Now would a VLF test been better to use or a discharge test your answer please ?What would have been the most effective way i wanted to replace the entire run but was stopped by others .Now there wishing it was done the fuses in MDP did not trip out but the shield inside cable is shorted to the core why or how can this be not effecting the trip .ZOG were are you !
Most Effective Cable Testing Methods Very Low Frequency (VLF) Test
Induces a low-frequency AC voltage to detect insulation defects, including moisture and aging. More sensitive than a megger test.
High-Potential (Hi-Pot) Test
Applies a high DC voltage to verify insulation integrity. Highly effective but can potentially damage aged cables.
Recommended Testing Approach
Given the age and history of the cable, the most effective approach would have been to:1. Conduct a VLF test on the old portion of the cable to detect any insulation weaknesses.
2. If the VLF test fails, perform a hi-pot test to confirm the insulation failure.3. Replace the entire cable run, as it is advisable to avoid using aged cables in critical applications.
Shield Shorting
The shield inside the cable may have shorted to the core due to: Mechanical damage
The track hoe impact could have caused punctures or abrasions in the insulation.
Moisture or contamination
Over time, moisture or other contaminants can penetrate the insulation and create a conductive path.
Improper installation
Incorrect cable termination or splicing can cause contact between the shield and the core.
Effect on Fuses
The fuses in the MDP may not have tripped out because: Low fault current
The short circuit path may be sufficiently resistive to limit the fault current below the trip threshold of the fuses.
Fuse damage
The fuses may be old or damaged and fail to operate properly.
Time-delay fuses
Time-delay fuses allow for a brief period of overcurrent before tripping, which may have prevented them from operating immediately.
Conclusion
In this case, a VLF test would have likely detected the insulation weakness in the old cable. Hi-pot testing could have confirmed the failure, but it was deemed too risky. The shorting of the shield to the core may have been caused by mechanical damage or other factors. It is important to use proper testing methods and follow industry best practices to ensure the safety and reliability of electrical cables. Flag for review