User: msjayhawk, Location: London, England
Asked on: Saturday, March 12, 2011 at 9:20 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 2:44 am EDT
Question: I have a "200 VAC" Ingersoll-Rand Air Compressor that I put in a few months ago. It is a good size unit, lubricated scroll, and about 11 horsepower. It is working fine and has about 70 hours run time on it since I put it in. It came with 670 hours (used deal), and I have put the other 70 on it hooked up to a high-leg delta connection (240 VAC, I guess).My problem is, my compressor people keep telling me I am going to burn it up, due to the high voltage and don't seem to understand the connection (most of them are young).My ELECTRICIANS, who are old tell me it is not a problem at all, and that it is actually a good thing because this motor is 'kind of hard to kick over', and it is not really 240 like you would think of as a 208 or something, I can be missing part of that.Anyway, I have had 200 VAC motor compressors hooked up to this system for 17 years, and never had a problem with a motor. I replaced the 5 hp with a 7.5 hp for the air I needed, and I replaced the 7.5 after 10 years just due to the need for more air.I am an ME, so this is all kind of confusing to me once you go past DC current The compressor guys are telling me I am going to kill the motor and void my warranty, and the electricians are saying they are 'full of stuff'. I tend to believe the electricians, as I have never had a 200 volt motor burn out on this exact same circuit.Any comments, Please??!!
Understanding the Voltage Connection The compressor is rated for 200 VAC, which indicates that it can operate on a voltage between 200 and 210 VAC. Your electrical system provides 240 VAC, which is within the acceptable range for the compressor.
Impact of Higher Voltage Running a motor at a slightly higher voltage than its rating can increase its speed and torque, but it can also lead to overheating. However, most motors have built-in protection mechanisms to prevent them from overheating due to voltage fluctuations.
Practical Experience You have successfully operated 200 VAC compressors on the same 240 VAC system for 17 years without any motor failures. This suggests that the higher voltage has not significantly impacted the lifespan of your compressors.
Electrical Opinion Electricians generally agree that connecting the compressor to a 240 VAC supply is acceptable and will not cause premature failure. They argue that the motor is designed to handle slight voltage variations and that the higher voltage may even be beneficial for overcoming initial resistance.
Compressor Manufacturer's Concerns Compressor manufacturers may advise against operating the unit at a higher voltage to protect themselves from potential warranty claims. They may have specific testing and specifications that differ from general electrical practices.
Recommendation
Based on your practical experience and the opinions of qualified electricians, it is unlikely that operating your 200 VAC compressor at 240 VAC will cause any significant issues. However, to ensure maximum lifespan and avoid any potential warranty concerns, you may want to consider the following: Contact the compressor manufacturer to confirm their voltage specifications and warranty terms. Monitor the compressor's temperature and performance to ensure it is operating within normal parameters.* If you experience any unusual behavior or overheating, disconnect the compressor and consult a qualified electrician or the manufacturer's support. Flag for review