User: letgomywago, Location: Washington state and Oregon coast
Asked on: Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 12:18 am EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 8:27 pm EDT
Question: I just saw a company is making these now. It's not cheap but idk I've always hated doing a 3r panel with romex. Hated arguing with the boss who'd say use a TA or a 2 in se connector.Now they just need to make this for other methods like mc or like a fancy reducing washer set that has like 3 (1/2) kos in it.
It sounds like you're describing a pre-fabricated, enclosed wiring panel designed for residential electrical installations using Romex (NM-B) cable, specifically for a "3R" panel (NEMA 3R rating, meaning rainproof and suitable for outdoor use). You're expressing a preference for this solution over traditional methods like using a Threaded Adapter (TA) or a 2-inch Service Entrance (SE) connector. You also desire similar solutions for other wiring methods like MC (Metal Clad) cable or a more versatile reducing washer system.Here's a breakdown of your points and some related considerations: Prefabricated 3R Panel with Romex Entry
The appeal here is primarily about ease of installation and a more professional, code-compliant appearance. Using TAs or SE connectors for Romex entry into a 3R panel can often feel awkward and may not always provide the best seal against weather. A dedicated pre-fab panel likely includes properly sized knockouts, strain relief, and potentially even integral bushings to protect the Romex cable.
Cost vs. Benefit
You acknowledge the higher cost, but this suggests that you believe the savings in labor, improved quality, and reduced potential for code violations may justify the expense. This is a common trade-off in electrical work.
Dislike of Traditional Methods
Your comment about "arguing with the boss" suggests potential issues with:
Code Compliance
Are the TA/SE connector installations truly meeting code requirements for strain relief, physical protection, and weatherproofing?
Aesthetics
Is the final result visually appealing and professional-looking?
Efficiency
How much time is being spent on these individual connections compared to a potentially faster pre-fabricated solution?
MC Cable Solution
A similar pre-fabricated panel designed for MC cable would be extremely valuable. The challenge here is that MC cable often requires grounding bushings or other specialized connectors to ensure proper grounding, which would need to be integrated into the design.
"Fancy Reducing Washer Set" with Multiple 1/2" KOs
This is an interesting idea. A reducing washer system that allows you to safely and securely run multiple smaller cables (like 1/2" conduit or fittings for smaller Romex/MC) through a single larger knockout would be a significant time-saver. It would need to be designed to:
Maintain Enclosure Rating
The washer system must not compromise the NEMA 3R rating of the panel.
Provide Strain Relief
Each cable entry point needs secure strain relief to prevent pulling on the conductors inside the panel.
Ensure Proper Grounding
For metal conduit or MC cable, the reducing washer system needs to facilitate proper grounding connections.
Meet Fill Requirements
The number of cables allowed through a single larger knockout needs to comply with code limitations for conduit fill.
Key Considerations and Potential Challenges
Code Compliance
Any pre-fabricated panel or reducing washer system must be listed and labeled by a recognized testing laboratory (e.g., UL, ETL) to ensure compliance with electrical codes.
Cost
Manufacturers need to balance the cost of development and production with a price point that electricians are willing to pay.
Market Demand
A niche product like this might have limited market demand, making it less attractive to manufacturers.
Standardization
The electrical industry could benefit from more standardization of cable entry methods for different enclosure types.
Overall:
Your ideas are valid and reflect a common desire among electricians for more efficient, reliable, and aesthetically pleasing solutions. While the up-front cost may be higher, the long-term benefits in terms of labor savings, improved quality, and reduced risk of code violations can make these types of products a worthwhile investment. You should communicate your ideas to manufacturers of electrical equipment. The more voices they hear, the more likely they are to produce the solutions you want. Flag for review