User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Friday, July 11, 2025 at 3:39 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, July 11, 2025 at 3:44 pm EDT
Question: Would any of you prefab pvc 80 duct banks and if so what would the criteria be to do so? Thank you for any feedback.
Yes, many contractors prefabricate PVC Schedule 80 duct banks under certain circumstances. Here's a breakdown of the criteria that would make prefabrication a good option
Advantages of Prefabrication (Why you'd WANT to do it):
Labor Cost Savings
This is often the biggest driver. Assembly in a controlled shop environment is typically faster and more efficient than field assembly. You can use jigs, fixtures, and specialized tools. Lower labor rates in a shop (compared to a field electrician) can also contribute.
Increased Quality Control
A shop environment allows for better supervision and adherence to standards. Consistent gluing, proper spacing, and accurate measurements are easier to achieve. Less environmental factors (rain, mud, etc.)
Reduced Field Congestion
Prefabricated sections arrive ready to be installed, reducing the amount of material and personnel on the job site, minimizing clutter and tripping hazards.
Faster Installation Time
Prefabrication significantly reduces on-site assembly time, allowing for quicker project completion. This is particularly beneficial in fast-paced projects.
Reduced Waste
Material can be managed more efficiently in a controlled environment, minimizing waste and potentially saving on material costs.
Improved Safety
Less cutting, gluing, and handling of materials in the field reduces the risk of injury.
Repeatability
For projects with many identical duct bank sections, prefabrication is ideal.
Criteria for Deciding to Prefabricate (When it MAKES SENSE)
Project Size and Complexity
Large Projects
Prefabrication is most cost-effective for projects with a significant amount of duct bank to be installed. The initial setup costs of prefabrication are offset by the savings on a larger scale.
Repetitive Sections
If the duct bank design includes repetitive sections (same number of conduits, same spacing, same lengths), prefabrication becomes much more attractive.
Complex Configurations
While it might seem counterintuitive, complex configurations with many bends, sweeps, and offsets can benefit from prefabrication. The precision possible in a shop can be invaluable.
Job Site Conditions
Congested Site
If the job site is cramped and difficult to work in, prefabrication can be a lifesaver.
Limited Access
If access to the installation area is restricted, prefabricated sections can be more easily maneuvered.
Weather Constraints
Inclement weather can significantly impact field assembly. Prefabrication allows work to continue in a controlled environment.
Transportation Considerations
Size and Weight
Can the pre-made sections be easily transported to the job site and maneuvered into position? Consider the size and weight limitations of trucks, cranes, and other equipment. This is a major limiting factor. Overly long or heavy sections will negate any time saved in the field.
Fragility
PVC, especially schedule 80, is relatively robust, but consider potential damage during transport. Proper packaging and securing of sections is crucial.
Design Stability
Confirmed Design
The duct bank design must be finalized and unlikely to change. Modifications to prefabricated sections can be costly and time-consuming. You need ACCURATE measurements!
Cost Analysis
Compare Costs
A thorough cost analysis is essential. Compare the cost of prefabrication (including shop labor, material, transportation, and setup) to the cost of field assembly (including field labor, material, potential delays, and rework).
Available Resources
Shop Space
Do you have access to a shop or warehouse with sufficient space to assemble the duct bank sections?
Equipment
Do you have the necessary equipment (saws, gluing stations, jigs, lifting equipment) to efficiently fabricate the duct bank sections?
Skilled Labor
Do you have trained personnel who can accurately assemble the duct bank sections according to the design specifications?
Company Capabilities
Experience
Does your company have experience with prefabrication? If not, consider starting with a smaller, simpler project to gain experience.
Coordination
Effective communication and coordination between the design team, the prefabrication shop, and the field installation crew is critical for success.
Specific Considerations for Schedule 80 PVC
Weight
Schedule 80 is thicker and heavier than Schedule 40. This increases transportation and handling challenges. Consider breaking the duct bank into smaller, more manageable sections.
Glueing
Proper gluing techniques are critical for Schedule 80 PVC. Ensure that your shop personnel are properly trained and that you are using the correct primer and cement. Use only approved glue and cleaners for schedule 80.
Support Spacing
Follow manufacturer's recommendations for support spacing, especially for buried duct banks. Prefabrication can help ensure that supports are properly placed and secured.*
Expansion/Contraction
PVC expands and contracts with temperature changes. Consider expansion joints or other methods to accommodate movement. Proper planning is more important with longer prefabricated runs.
In summary:
Prefabrication of PVC Schedule 80 duct banks can be a very worthwhile endeavor, especially for large, repetitive projects in congested or weather-sensitive environments. However, careful planning, a detailed cost analysis, and a thorough understanding of the project's constraints are essential for success. The single most important factor is determining if the time saved in the field is worth the cost of transportation of these large pieces. If the sections are very large, and require special permitting and transportation, it may not be worth the effort. Flag for review