The ideal location for synch gear depends on the specific requirements and preferences of the facility. Here are the pros and cons of each option

Within sight of the generators:
Pros

Allows the operator to visually monitor the generators and synch gear during the synchronization process. Provides easy access for maintenance and troubleshooting.

Cons

Can be exposed to harsh conditions (e.g., noise, vibration, heat) that may affect the performance of the synch gear. May require additional safety measures to prevent unauthorized access.

Within the main electrical room



Pros

Located in a controlled environment, reducing exposure to harsh conditions. Close proximity to other critical electrical equipment (e.g., ATS, LVSG, transformers) for easy coordination and monitoring. Improved security and access control.

Cons

Requires longer cable runs between the generators and the synch gear, which can introduce signal interference and voltage drop. May not provide the operator with a direct line of sight to the generators, potentially limiting visual monitoring.Ultimately, the best location should be determined based on the following factors:

Facility layout

Consider the physical proximity of the generators, electrical room, and other relevant equipment.

Operational requirements

Determine if visual monitoring is essential or if remote monitoring is sufficient.

Safety considerations

Evaluate the potential risks and mitigation measures for exposure to hazards.*

Maintenance access: Ensure that the synch gear is easily accessible for routine maintenance and repairs.In your case, if the priority is on visual monitoring and the electrical room is close to the generators, then locating the synch gear within the electrical room may be the optimal choice. However, if remote monitoring is sufficient and there are concerns about harsh conditions, then placing the synch gear within sight of the generators may be more appropriate. Flag for review