User: kjroller, Location: Dawson Mn
Asked on: Monday, May 12, 2025 at 1:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 8:24 pm EDT
Question: I work in a Industrial Processing plant I have a Fire Alarm System, E light system and a Gas Sniffing system required by the state all on backup batterys. If I want to power the panel they are fed out of with a generator are they considered emergency loads or is this a optional standby system since they are already battery back up? The reason I ask is because this panel feeds other loads as well and if it is emergency im under the impression cannot mix the two loads without another trandferswitch. Let me know what you think!
Okay, let's break this down. This is a common situation, and the key is understanding the definitions and requirements of emergency systems versus optional standby systems.
Key Definitions (based on NFPA 70, the National Electrical Code)
Emergency Systems (Article 700)
These systems are legally required and intended to supply power automatically to specific areas and equipment vital to life safety during a power outage. These are critical for the safety of building occupants.
Legally Required Standby Systems (Article 701)
These systems are required by a governmental agency (federal, state, local, or other governing agency, but typically NOT an insurance company) to supply power to specific loads that, if interrupted, could create hazards or hamper rescue or fire-fighting operations.
Optional Standby Systems (Article 702)
These systems are designed to supply power to loads that are not necessarily life-safety critical but are important for business continuity, comfort, or convenience.
Analysis of Your Systems
Fire Alarm System
This is almost certainly an
Emergency System. It's legally required (you mention the state mandates it), and its purpose is to protect life safety during a fire. It must operate reliably during a power outage.2. Emergency Lighting (E-lights)
This is almost certainly an
Emergency System. It's designed to provide illumination to exit pathways and critical areas during a power outage, directly impacting life safety.3. Gas Sniffing System
This could be either
Emergency System or Legally Required Standby System, depending on the state requirements. If the state requires the system to prevent explosions or hazardous conditions specifically during a power outage to protect life and property, it is likely legally required. If not, or if the state only requires the system to be available during normal operation, then it may be an optional standby system.
Battery Backup Considerations
The fact that these systems already have battery backup does
not automatically disqualify them from being considered Emergency Systems or Legally Required Standby Systems. Batteries are often part of an emergency power system design. The generator would act as an additional layer of reliability, especially for prolonged outages, and to recharge the batteries.
Mixing Loads on an Emergency System
This is where the question of whether the panel feeds other loads comes into play.
Generally, you cannot mix Emergency System loads with non-Emergency loads on the same transfer switch and generator without proper separation and control.NEC (NFPA 70) Concerns
700.8 Wiring of Emergency Circuits
This section of the NEC strictly regulates how Emergency System wiring is installed and separated from normal power wiring.
700.9 Transfer Equipment
This section requires transfer equipment for Emergency Systems to be specifically approved for emergency use.
700.12 General Requirements
This section prohibits emergency systems from being used for non-emergency purposes.
Why the Separation is Necessary
Reliability
You don't want a non-emergency load failure to potentially compromise the operation of the emergency systems.
Code Compliance
The NEC (and likely your state electrical code) mandates separation.
Load Shedding
Emergency generators are often sized specifically for the emergency loads. Adding other loads could overload the generator during an outage.
Recommendations and Next Steps
Consult with an Electrical Engineer
This is the most important step. An experienced electrical engineer specializing in emergency power systems can: Review your state's specific requirements for fire alarm, emergency lighting, and gas detection systems. Determine the exact classification of each of your systems (Emergency, Legally Required, or Optional). Assess the existing panel and wiring. Design a generator system that meets code requirements and provides the necessary power, including proper transfer switch configurations.2.
Contact the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)
This is typically your local building or electrical inspector. They will have the final say on whether your system meets code. Get their input early in the design process.3.
Consider Separate Transfer Switches
If you want to power the panel with a generator and the panel feeds both emergency and non-emergency loads, you will likely need separate transfer switches:
One transfer switch dedicated only to the emergency loads (fire alarm, emergency lighting, potentially the gas detection system depending on its classification). This transfer switch would be specifically designed and approved for emergency system use. Another transfer switch for the non-emergency loads powered by the panel. This can be a standard transfer switch.
Example Scenario
Let's say the panel currently powers: Fire Alarm System Emergency Lighting Gas Detection System (Legally Required Standby per your state) General Lighting in a non-critical area A non-essential control systemIn this case, the best approach would be:1. Install a dedicated Emergency System transfer switch to power the Fire Alarm, Emergency Lighting and Gas Detection Systems2. Install a separate Optional Standby System transfer switch to power the General Lighting and non-essential control system.
In summary, proceed with caution and involve qualified professionals. Incorrectly implementing an emergency power system can have serious legal and safety consequences. Flag for review